Close Menu
NERDBOT
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    Subscribe
    NERDBOT
    • News
      • Reviews
    • Movies & TV
    • Comics
    • Gaming
    • Collectibles
    • Science & Tech
    • Culture
    • Nerd Voices
    • About Us
      • Join the Team at Nerdbot
    NERDBOT
    Home»Movies»‘Shape Of Water’ Lawsuit Dismissed by Judge
    Movies

    ‘Shape Of Water’ Lawsuit Dismissed by Judge

    Loryn StoneBy Loryn StoneJuly 24, 20183 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest Reddit WhatsApp Email

    Deadline reports that a federal judge has dismissed with prejudice a lawsuit filed by the estate of playwright Paul Zindel accusing filmmaker Guillermo del Toro of appropriating plot elements from Let Me Hear You Whisper in his Oscar-winning film The Shape of Water. The suit was filed and fanned for maximum publicity on the day that Academy voters began filling out their final ballots for major category nominees, this after an ask for a settlement was rebuffed by Fox Searchlight. The film won four Oscars anyway, including Best Picture and Best Director for del Toro.

    The copyright infringement claim, filed in February in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles, alleges del Toro “brazenly copies the story, elements, characters, and themes” from a work by Pulitzer-Prize-winning author Zindel’s 1969 play, which describes a lonely janitorial cleaning woman who works the graveyard shift at a scientific laboratory facility that performs animal experiments for military use. There she becomes fascinated by a fantastic intelligent aquatic creature, held captive in a glass tank. When she learns of plans to kill the creature, she liberates it in a rolling laundry cart and releases it at a dock that feeds into the ocean.

    Del Toro emphatically denied the allegations, and defended his film and his own integrity in a Deadline interview.

    “I have never read nor seen the play,” del Toro told Deadline. “I’d never heard of this play before making The Shape of Water, and none of my collaborators ever mentioned the play.

    “I have been at this 25 years and have an unimpeachable reputation,” he said. “I have always made it an element of my career to talk about my influences in every single movie I have made, in the comment track of DVDs, on Twitter, in my museum exhibitions. I have been open about the things I love, and I have had no problem discussing them and how they were transformational in my movies. This 25 year trajectory should come in handy. I have written or co-written about 24 screenplays. I am a writer/director who has generated TV series, books, movies and an enormous amount of screenplays through the years. Without a single complaint.”

    Fox’s attorneys similarly argued in court papers that “the works are completely dissimilar.”  The play, they argued, is a straightforward story exploring the evils of animal experimentation, in which a cleaning woman in a small lab convinces a dolphin to talk — thus preventing its extermination by scientists. The film, by contrast, is “a decidedly adult meld of genres” that includes a romantic and sexual relationship between Elisa, a female janitor who doesn’t speak, and a humanoid amphibian with god-like powers.

    “Any “similarity” between these vastly different works derives from the non-protectable idea of a relationship between a person and an animal (in the case of the Play) or mythical humanoid creature (in the case of the Film) that scientists wish to kill and/or study and experiment on—an idea that has previously been the subject of numerous films, including Free Willy, Starman, Splash!, Project X, and E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial,” wrote Edward K. Lee on behalf of Fox.

    The court agreed with Fox’s interpretation.

    Do You Want to Know More?

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Email
    Previous ArticleEnter The Dragon is Getting a Remake by Deadpool 2 Director
    Next Article Top 5 Best Houses from 90s Movies
    Loryn Stone
    • Website
    • Facebook
    • X (Twitter)
    • Instagram

    Loryn Stone has dedicated her life to the written Word of the Nerd. Her writing has also been published on other pop culture websites such as Cracked, LoadScreen, PopLurker, and Temple of Geek. Her debut young-adult novel "My Starlight" (a contemporary love letter to fandom, friendship, anime, cosplaying, love, and loss) is out now by Affinity Rainbow Publications. When she's not writing, Loryn's other interests include collecting robots (Megazords, specifically), playing bass, and blasting metal.

    Related Posts

    Link, Zelda Cast for Live-Action “Legend of Zelda” Film

    July 16, 2025

    “Life After” Impartial Exposé on Complex, Important Issues [Review]

    July 15, 2025

    Sarah Jessica Parker Gives Surprising “Hocus Pocus 3” Update

    July 15, 2025

    Jeffrey Combs Joins “Mystery of the Mothman” Cast

    July 15, 2025

    Nintendo Files Copyright for “Donkey Kong” Movie

    July 14, 2025

    Aaron Sorkin Set to Direct New Follow-Up to The Social Network at Sony Pictures

    July 13, 2025
    • Latest
    • News
    • Movies
    • TV
    • Reviews

    The Hidden World of Escape from Tarkov Cheats: What You Need to Know

    July 16, 2025

    What Are Some Apparel Brand Name Suggestions for a New Fashion Startup

    July 16, 2025

    Elevate Your Business with Premium Branding & Digital Product Design Services

    July 16, 2025

    Is Using an SMM Panel Safe? Pros and Cons

    July 16, 2025

    “Life After” Impartial Exposé on Complex, Important Issues [Review]

    July 15, 2025

    Nominations for the 77th Annual Emmys

    July 15, 2025

    UNO Denies Las Vegas Casino but Announces Social Clubs

    July 14, 2025
    Human Skin Bear

    A Teddy Bear Seemingly Wrapped in Human Skin Found

    July 14, 2025

    Link, Zelda Cast for Live-Action “Legend of Zelda” Film

    July 16, 2025

    “Life After” Impartial Exposé on Complex, Important Issues [Review]

    July 15, 2025

    Sarah Jessica Parker Gives Surprising “Hocus Pocus 3” Update

    July 15, 2025

    Jeffrey Combs Joins “Mystery of the Mothman” Cast

    July 15, 2025

    “Stranger Things” Final Season Gets Official Teaser

    July 16, 2025

    HBO Reveals First Look at New Harry Potter Actor in Costume

    July 14, 2025

    Zach Braff, Donald Faison, Sarah Chalke Return for “Scrubs” Reboot

    July 11, 2025

    Larry David Returns to HBO with American History Sketch Show

    July 10, 2025

    “Life After” Impartial Exposé on Complex, Important Issues [Review]

    July 15, 2025

    “Superman” Big, Beautiful Mess Bursting With Color, Hope [Review]

    July 11, 2025

    James Gunn’s “Superman” Brings Updated Meaning to the Man of Steel [Spoiler-Free Review]

    July 8, 2025

    The F11PRO 2 Drone – Pro-Level Performance Meets Sleek Design

    July 3, 2025
    Check Out Our Latest
      • Product Reviews
      • Reviews
      • SDCC 2021
      • SDCC 2022
    Related Posts

    None found

    NERDBOT
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    Nerdbot is owned and operated by Nerds! If you have an idea for a story or a cool project send us a holler on [email protected]

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.