NERDBOT
    Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube
    Subscribe
    NERDBOT
    • News
      • Reviews
    • Movies & TV
    • Comics
    • Gaming
    • Collectibles
    • Science & Tech
    • Nerd Culture
    • About Us
      • Want to Write for Nerdbot?
    NERDBOT
    Home»News»Court Rules Ana de Armas Fans Can Sue Over “Yesterday” Trailer
    Ana de Armas "Blade Runner 2049" Warner Bros. Pictures
    News

    Court Rules Ana de Armas Fans Can Sue Over “Yesterday” Trailer

    Amy DavisBy Amy DavisDecember 23, 2022Updated:December 23, 20223 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest Reddit WhatsApp Email

    Two fans of actress Ana de Armas filed a lawsuit in January after renting the 2019 film “Yesterday.” The plaintiffs, Conor Woulfe and Peter Michael Rosza, filed the suit after they rented the film for $3.99 on Amazon Prime. Their issue is, while de Armas is featured in the trailer, she does not appear in the film. Their argument is the trailer misrepresents the film, and they would not have rented it if they had known she wasn’t in it.

    “Yesterday,” revolves around a young man who wakes up after a bicycle crash, only to find out somehow no one on earth seems to remember The Beatles. So he does what any reasonable person would do; performs their songs himself and become rich and famous. 

    “Yesterday,” Universal Pictures

    Originally, de Armas appeared “Yesterday” as part of a love triangle between her, protagonist Himesh Patel, and Lily James. The pair were to meet on James Corden‘s talk show where Patel serenade her with the song “Something.” The issue is, test audiences hated Patel stepping out on his main love interest, James so de Armas was cut. A decision that screenwriter Richard Curtis described as a  “very traumatic cut.” But she is still featured in the trailer.

    Now to be clear this lawsuit isn’t just about some disappointed fans seeking $5 million against the films distributor, Universal Pictures. It is about whether or not trailers are considered free or commercial speech. Which, legally speaking, is a huge distinction between what studios can and cannot put in them. Universal is arguing trailers are “artistic, expressive work.” They should be treated are three-minute stories that are more to convey the themes and ideas of a movie. 

    "Yesterday" poster
    “Yesterday” poster (Universal)

    “What is obvious about trailers generally and the Yesterday trailer in particular: they are expressive works in their own right and may not be relegated to a class of ‘purely commercial’ speech that receives watered-down First Amendment protection,” lawyers for Universal said in a motion. They also used a “ Jurassic Park” trailer that was composed of footage that never appeared in the film as an example. 

    California US district judge Stephen Wilson disagrees with this argument and would not allow the case to be thrown out like Universal wants. “Universal is correct that trailers involve some creativity and editorial discretion, but this creativity does not outweigh the commercial nature of a trailer,” Wilson wrote in the ruling. “At its core, a trailer is an advertisement designed to sell a movie by providing consumers with a preview of the movie.”

    It’s not that de Armas’ role was cut down and she wasn’t a lead character. She straight-up isn’t even in “Yesterday.” If we are to view a trailer as an advertisement for a film, as most people would, we were shown a character that doesn’t even exist. Not just a scene or some footage like the “Jurassic Park” trailer. This is a whole person and subplot that just flat-out don’t exist in the film. 

    Due to Wilson’s ruling, Woulfe and Rosza’s lawsuit will proceed to discovery and a motion for class certification. No matter the outcome this case, defining movie trailers as either free or commercial speech will have a serious impact on what studios can and cannot do from now on.

    You can see one of the trailers in question for yourself below:

    Author

    Amy Davis
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Email
    Previous ArticlePenguins Visit Elderly Patients for Christmas in the UK
    Next Article H&M Pulls Justin Bieber Mechandise After He Called Brand “Trash”
    Amy Davis

    Related Posts

    J.Lo’s “Shotgun Wedding” is an “I Don’t” [Review]

    January 27, 2023

    Jay Leno Suffers Another Accident- Multiple Broken Bones

    January 27, 2023
    Budweiser flower arrangement

    Budweiser Develops Unique Valentine’s Day Gift

    January 27, 2023

    There’s a Reason Pink Waves Are Hitting California Shoreline

    January 27, 2023

    WATCH: Disney 100th Celebration Live from Disneyland

    January 27, 2023

    Fireball Facing $5 Million Lawsuit Over Mini Bottles

    January 27, 2023
    • Trending
    • Latest
    • Movies
    • TV

    Christian Activist Suing The NFL For $867 Trillion Over Half-Time Show

    February 5, 2020

    Marvel Eyeing GOT Star Nathalie Emmanuel To Play The MCU’s Storm

    June 27, 2019

    Rumor: Charlie Hunnam In Talks For New Wolverine Movie

    May 20, 2019

    Scientists Are Actually Trying to Open a Portal to a Mirror Universe(Yes Really)

    December 28, 2019

    J.Lo’s “Shotgun Wedding” is an “I Don’t” [Review]

    January 27, 2023

    Tobey Maguire Would LOVE to Do 5th “Spider-Man”

    January 27, 2023

    Jay Leno Suffers Another Accident- Multiple Broken Bones

    January 27, 2023
    "Children of the Corn"

    “Children Of The Corn” Remake Finally Gets Release Date

    January 27, 2023

    J.Lo’s “Shotgun Wedding” is an “I Don’t” [Review]

    January 27, 2023

    Tobey Maguire Would LOVE to Do 5th “Spider-Man”

    January 27, 2023
    "Children of the Corn"

    “Children Of The Corn” Remake Finally Gets Release Date

    January 27, 2023

    Ayo Edebiri Joins Marvel Studios’ “Thunderbolts” in Mystery Role

    January 26, 2023
    "Jay Leno's Garage"

    Jay Leno’s 30-Year NBC Run Comes to an End

    January 27, 2023

    Phoebe Waller-Bridge Writing Amazon’s “Tomb Raider” Series

    January 27, 2023

    “Frasier” Revival Reveals Son of Niles and Daphne

    January 27, 2023

    HBO Orders Season 2 of “The Last of Us”

    January 27, 2023
    Related Posts

    None found

    San Diego Comic-Con
      • auction
      • carnivorous plant
      • dinosaur
      • pennyworth
      • San Diego Comic-Con
    NERDBOT
    Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube
    © 2023 NERDBOT Media

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.