Close Menu
NERDBOT
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    Subscribe
    NERDBOT
    • News
      • Reviews
    • Movies & TV
    • Comics
    • Gaming
    • Collectibles
    • Science & Tech
    • Culture
    • Nerd Voices
    • About Us
      • Join the Team at Nerdbot
    NERDBOT
    Home»News»Supreme Court Rules Against Andy Warhol in Dispute Over Prince Image
    Unsplash
    News

    Supreme Court Rules Against Andy Warhol in Dispute Over Prince Image

    Amy DavisBy Amy DavisMay 19, 20233 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest Reddit WhatsApp Email

    The Supreme Court has ruled artist Andy Warhol violated copyright law with images of the late singer Prince. The dispute involves images created as a commission for Vanity Fair by Warhol in 1984. The artist used photographs of Prince taken by Lynn Goldsmith as a reference point. Vanity Fair paid Goldsmith to license the photo, but when Warhol created his pieces, he did not pay for or acquire any rights to the photos.

    Vanity Fair ultimately choose one of these images, Prince with a purple face, to run in the magazine. Then they ran another image from the series after the singer passed away in 2016. This second image is what is being contested in court.

    The ruling was 7-2 against Warhol’s work. “Lynn Goldsmith’s original works, like those of other photographers, are entitled to copyright protection, even against famous artists,” Justice Sonia Sotomayor and six of her colleagues wrote. 

    Lawyers for The Andy Warhol Foundation maintain that the silk-screened pieces transformed the work enough that they don’t violate copyright law. Under “fair use” copyright laws some amount of inspiration or borrowing from other artists is allowed. Since, realistically, making a wholly original work of art is almost impossible. The Federal Copyright Act of 1976 does outline four factors to determine if something falls under fair use:

    • The Purpose and Character of the Use.
    • The Nature of the Copyrighted Work.
    • The Amount or Substantiality of the Portion Used.
    • The Effect of the Use on the Potential Market for or Value of the Work.

    But even with that criteria, rulings like this can still be highly subjective. This is why you have Justices like Elena Kagan arguing that this ruling will “stifle creativity of every sort.”

    Kagan believes that the majority overlooked the fact that the silkscreen and photo do not have the same “aesthetic characteristics.” Nor does she feel that they “convey the same meaning.” Instead, her peers only focused on the commercial purpose of the work. Something that “ill serves copyright’s core purpose,” she said.

    “Both Congress and the courts have long recognized that an overly stringent copyright regime actually stifles creativity by preventing artists from building on the works of others,” Kegan wrote. “Artists don’t create all on their own; they cannot do what they do without borrowing from or otherwise making use of the work of others,” she explained. She is of the belief that Warhol’s “eye-popping” interpretation of Prince “dramatically” altered Goldsmith’s photograph. 

    “Although the majority opinion focuses on only one of the four factors courts are supposed to apply in determining when works of art can be fairly used by others, there’s little question that the majority opinion will have a major impact on these kinds of reproductions – making it harder for artists to repurpose the works of others even with meaningful differences (and not just reproduce them), without their permission,” Steve Vladeck, a CNN Supreme Court analyst and professor at the University of Texas School of Law, said.

    “Indeed, whether one thinks Justice Sotomayor’s majority opinion or Justice Kagan’s dissent has the better of the legal arguments, it’s hard to disagree with Kagan that such an approach could ‘stifle creativity’ across a range of artistic media – and that perhaps Congress ought to revisit whether this is the best outcome,” he said.

    This ruling will have a major impact on how work is determined to be transformative in the future. 

    Do You Want to Know More?

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Email
    Previous ArticleStablecoins and Price Stability: How They Mitigate Volatility in Crypto
    Next Article 10th Annual Etheria Film Festival Announces Dates, Lineup
    Amy Davis

    Hi, I’m Amy. I like long walks in the graveyard, horror movies, comic books, and bringing you the latest in nerd-centric news.

    Related Posts

    How to Use Tetris for PTSD Recovery: A Science-Backed Guide

    May 7, 2025

    Funko Announces Price Increases Due to…Reasons

    May 6, 2025
    A Million Lives Book Festival

    Authors Lose Thousands at Failed ‘A Million Lives Book Festival’

    May 6, 2025

    Boost Your Confidence Between the Sheets Today

    May 6, 2025
    Snake that fell into a drink at Patron Mexican Restaurant and Cantina in Sandston, VA

    Virginia Woman Rattled After Snake Falls Into Her Margarita

    May 5, 2025
    Alcatraz, as seen from Pier 39.

    Donald Trump Wants to ‘Rebuild and Open’ Alcatraz Prison

    May 5, 2025
    • Latest
    • News
    • Movies
    • TV
    • Reviews

    Jessica Jones Confirmed for “Daredevil: Born Again” Season 2

    May 13, 2025

    Six Sigma Green Belt Certification: Building Strong Foundations in Quality Management

    May 13, 2025

    Relapse in the Spotlight: How Celebrities Handle Public Recovery Setbacks

    May 13, 2025

    Robert Downey Jr.’s Comeback: How Recovery Gave Him a Second Chance at Life and Career

    May 13, 2025

    How to Use Tetris for PTSD Recovery: A Science-Backed Guide

    May 7, 2025

    Funko Announces Price Increases Due to…Reasons

    May 6, 2025
    A Million Lives Book Festival

    Authors Lose Thousands at Failed ‘A Million Lives Book Festival’

    May 6, 2025

    Boost Your Confidence Between the Sheets Today

    May 6, 2025
    Tom Cruise on top of London’s BFI Imax cinema

    Tom Cruise Spotted on Roof of London’s BFI IMAX

    May 12, 2025

    Cameras to Roll on “Highlander” Reboot this September

    May 9, 2025

    Cameras are Rolling on “Godzilla X Kong: Supernova”

    May 9, 2025
    "Evil Dead Rise"

    “Evil Dead” Sequel Lands Release Date

    May 8, 2025

    Jessica Jones Confirmed for “Daredevil: Born Again” Season 2

    May 13, 2025

    “Alien: Earth” Gets New Images, August Release Date

    May 13, 2025

    “The Office” Spinoff “The Paper” Gets Fall 2025 Release

    May 12, 2025
    "Ted," 2024

    Seth MacFarlane’s “Ted” Gets Animated Series, Teaser

    May 9, 2025

    “Friendship” The Funniest Movie I Couldn’t Wait to End [review]

    May 3, 2025

    “Thunderbolts*” Surprisingly Emotional Therapy Session for Anti-Heroes

    May 3, 2025

    “Sinners” is Sexy, Boozy, Bloody, Bluesy, and Amazing [Review]

    April 18, 2025

    “The Legend of Ochi” Cute Puppets, But No Magic [Review]

    April 16, 2025
    Check Out Our Latest
      • Product Reviews
      • Reviews
      • SDCC 2021
      • SDCC 2022
    Related Posts

    None found

    NERDBOT
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    Nerdbot is owned and operated by Nerds! If you have an idea for a story or a cool project send us a holler on [email protected]

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.