Do you love classic Italian food like bruschetta, pizza, risotto, and chicken cacciatore? Are you looking for a restaurant that serves your favorites and also has a great atmosphere, top-notch service, and a curated wine list? If so, you might try searching authentic Italian restaurants near me or you might ask around to friends and family members who love going out to eat in the Tinton Falls, New Jersey area. No matter which you do, you’re likely to find at least a few of these local gems!

Gargiulo’s 

Gargiulo’s is one of the authentic Italian restaurants near me that always tops every local’s list! In business for 50 years in Brooklyn, the Russo family decided to bring their classic Neopolitan fare to Tinton Falls. Closed on Tuesdays but open every other day of the week for lunch and dinner, Gargiulo’s has a menu filled with delicious apps like stuffed artichokes and calamari, a variety of pizzas and sandwiches, classic pasta dishes, and entrees like chicken scarpariello and pan-seared halibut with lobster cream sauce. The restaurant also has regular wine pairing dinners, live music, and a wine shoppe where you can learn more about wine or pick out the perfect bottle. 

Jimmy Pecci’s Taste of Italy 

If you want an authentic Italian meal catered in to your next party or work function, Jimmy Pecci’s is a great option. Their homemade prepared entrees, pastas, subs, and desserts are all prepared fresh daily and you’ll have no problem finding something for everyone from their huge menu. You can also add on specialty side salads like antipasto salad or tortellini salad or marinated vegetables and olives to make your spread even more appealing. Want to stop in for lunch instead of getting a meal catered in? You can do that, too! Choose from their selection of wraps or signature subs or pop in to shop their Italian market to make your own meal at home.

Nettie’s House of Spaghetti 

If you Google authentic Italian restaurants near me, don’t pass up Nettie’s House of Spaghetti because you think it has a funny name! This is actually a very high-end dinner restaurant and is the perfect spot to celebrate a special occasion or have a date night. Start your meal with house-made pickled veggies or 24-month parmigianno reggiano with pasta crackers, then move on to pan roasted branzino with fried mushrooms or fresh cavatini with sweat peas, red sauce, and romano cheese. Complement your meal with a Nettie’s Negroni served on tap, an Italian Job (Italian gin and Italian vermouth served extra cold with an olive and a twist) or a glass of red or white from their Italian-focused selection of wines. 

The Best Authentic Italian Restaurants Near Me 

Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch, want to cater in a meal, or are searching for the perfect spot for your next date night, you can find what you’re looking for in Tinton Falls! When you visit one of these three authentic Italian restaurants near me, you will be guaranteed a satisfying meal with impeccable service.